Can an Autumn wear black?
March 2nd, 2010 by Kim BolsoverTin hats at the ready. This is a rant!
When I’m introducing colour analysis as a new concept, I always take time to talk about the history of this fascinating subject and that, inevitably, leads to questions about some of the idiotic ideas that have emerged from this relatively modern way of analysing people and their personality.
What I find both fascinating and infuriating is how some of these outdated notions still continue to prevail even when common sense and practical application prove that they’re a load of old tosh.
The biggest most-stupid-on-the-planet myth is that only Winters can wear black.
Oh, lead me to a darkened room, pour me a huge gin and tonic, and leave me alone so I can scream until I’m blue in the face and bite huge chunks out of my pillow.
The sheer stupidity of this statement is beyond belief.
Who the heck says that only Winters can wear black?
- Is there a scientist in the entire universe who has proven this beyond all possible doubt?
- Is there a university-level standard that every single image consultant around the globe subscribes to under pain of having their left leg chopped off?
No and no - are the answers to the above, and do you know why?
Because we’re dealing with human beings and you can’t drop human beings into 4 convenient little boxes like Spring, Summer, Autumn or Winter, because human beings are a moving target and are totally and utterly indefinable. And I say, thank glory for that, otherwise I’d have given up this great career yonks ago out of sheer and utter boredom.
So who is it exactly that says only Winters can wear black?
Those pioneers who put pen to paper in the early days of colour analysis came up with all sorts of attempts at regularising the process. I can only surmise that this was intended to make it easier for those who were training to become colour consultants.
Maybe they insisted on a step-by-step, cannot-be-argued-with diagnosis of hair, skin and eye colour to make ‘their’ consultations easier? Because of their insatiable need to know whether they’d ‘got it right’ or not, we’ve now ended up with tables of impractical rules and regulations that completely miss the point anyway.
We have moved on so much since those pioneering days. We continue to learn at an astounding rate with every new client that crosses our portal and yet some folk seem determined to cling on to these out-dated rules as though their very life depends upon it.
Enough is enough.
Colour analysis isn’t about rules
Because there aren’t any. There can’t be. We’re dealing with a moving target - human beings - who change on a daily basis, some from hour to hour (just ask a menopausal woman how she felt an hour ago!).
We have so many parameters to take into account - occasions to be appropriately dressed for, other people’s expectations to meet, and our own personality. How on earth can a set of ‘rules’ cater for real life?
How do you FEEL?
- If you LOOK good in black, then why not wear it?
- If, however, you FEEL fabulous in black, then for goodness sake stop listening to someone else’s inane rules and wear it immediately!
Here’s a great example of someone who shouldn’t - according to the ‘rules’ - be wearing black at all but looks fabulous and feels wonderfully confident about wearing it.
These two photos of my friend Jean were taken while we were modelling together at a recent fashion show:
![]() |
![]() |
Jean is a Classic Autumn. And she looks lovely in black. More to the point, she feels fabulous wearing black.
When we first started working together on her wardrobe, Jean wasn’t happy in black at all. She’d been told previously that, as an Autumn, she shouldn’t wear it so she didn’t!
But as we started to find clothes that suited her colouring, her body shape AND her personality all together, we both realised that black was going to play a much larger role in shaping her overall image.
We began with accessories, matching shoes and handbags in black, the ubiquitous black trousers, gloves, and necklaces. Then, one day on a shopping trip, I managed to get her to try on a black top.
Ok, ok, I lie. I shoved the top into the changing booth and told her in no uncertain terms that she was not to come out unless she was wearing it! Jean is a good sport and trusts me that I wouldn’t put her in anything that would make her look ghastly.
She was really surprised by how good she looked and although neither of us would want to see her in nothing but black from head to foot, black is now a great addition to Jean’s wardrobe - as you can see.
Oh, and you’ll notice how Jean’s hair colour puts to rest yet another moronic, mindless myth - that all Autumns and Winters must have dark hair.
What a pile of poppycock - but if you get me started on that one, I’ll still be ranting as they lower me six feet under..


Over the years, I have managed to kill off at least half a dozen perfectly innocent basil plants.